Ordinary

Tom H

9 months ago

Fantastic artisanal cocktails with exceptional service in a wonderful speakeasy atmosphere. The food was also great, although a little limited in selection. But everything that we tried was very tasty.

Xiomari Caban Garcia

4 months ago

The environment, atmosphere, & ambience was 10/10. Good drink selection , great spot to gather with a good group of friends for a night out. Friendly service.

Darshil Patel

a year ago

Ordinary is a true speakeasy experience—true to its name, you could easily miss it if you’re not paying attention! It used to be the Taft Hotel's bar, which adds a charming bit of history to the place. Every time I visit, I’m impressed by both the food and drinks. We tried the mac & cheese, grilled cheese, candied nuts, and roasted potatoes, and everything was spot on. But the real highlight is the drinks—my go-to is the sour amaretto with egg whites, and they do a phenomenal job every single time! If you're looking for a hidden gem with excellent food and standout cocktails, Ordinary is a must-visit when in New Haven!

mike gonzalez (RatedByMike)

11 months ago

From the moment you walk in, Ordinary hits you with that speakeasy-style charm hidden behind a door that feels like it belongs in the Prohibition era. It’s got this moody, vintage vibe that sets the tone before you even sit down. The food Not bad at all believe it or not, some of the bites definitely hold their own. But let’s be real the star of the show is hands-down the chocolate chip cookies. Gooey, rich, and warm, they come out like they were baked by someone who understands your soul. Seriously, don’t skip them. Whether you’re there for a chill night out, good conversation, or just want to feel like you’re sipping cocktails in a hidden 1920s bar Ordinary delivers. Just save room for dessert. Trust me.

Ms. Miami

6 months ago

The mystery of it all is really cool. Love the hidden bar and the theme. The bartenders are very professional and the drinks are perfect. I got the Vampires kiss which was delicious and really cool at the same time. Had a good time period .

Cosima Kymissis

5 months ago

Absolutely adorable spot. It’s a cute little speakeasy that is now Christmas themed with a really fun and inventive menu. We spent a good while here and had a great time. It was an intimate vibe, and the drinks were very good.

Gily Raz

3 months ago

Went here for Happy Hour. The place is beautifully decorated, and the vibe is incredible. I could sit there for hours. It has a warm, inviting ambiance that is perfect for meeting up with a friend and catching up. I think it was the nostalgia of a Gremlin on the light fixture for me that cemented this place in my heart! Well-worth a stop if you’re in New Haven. Metered street parking (paid) is available right outside, for your convenience.

shaisky urena

5 months ago

amazing experience. We were walked through the menu and given amazing recommendations. Marcelo was a 10/10, he was a great bartender we told him what we liked and he made sure our drinks reflected that. It is very rare that we have great drinks, food and service! If you are in New Haven I 100% would recommend this place! The place was also comfortable and they had plenty of seating.

Ciana Belton

5 months ago

I stopped by Ordinary for a nightcap with my boyfriend on our date night and it DID NOT disappoint! They are currently in the holiday spirit with lots of winter themed drinks and decor. They have an EXPANSIVE selection of liqueurs and spirits. I found a few new things to try while just sitting at the bar. They also serve a few late night bites. We tried the Brown Butter Choco Cookies…to die for! Our bartenders were super sweet and even made us some special creative holiday shots (for a price of course lol). They have specials on a daily basis too. We were there on a Tuesday and got our “Vinylry” cocktails for just $10! The drinks were great, the people were friendly, the music was good, and the atmosphere was amazing. Holiday season or not, I definitely recommend if you’re looking for a chill evening out or a quick drink.

Hector Ramirez

4 months ago

First time in CT. and what are the odds we meet these incredible people. One of the owners, Ben gave us a printed list of the spots to check out in the area and meanwhile, Marcelo, the mixologist whipped up some of the finest cocktails we’ve ever had. We gave him our profile and he did the rest. Wish we had more time to spend here, but in the span of 2 drinks this is easily one of the best bars I’ve ever been to. 5 stars isn’t enough. Such a vibe